December 15, 2003

Taxicarbussharing

Posted by tomo at 12:58 AM in transportation . | 8 Comments

Recently, I learned about Taxibus, a new hi-tech dynamically-routed microbussing solution in the UK, "Revolutionary Urban Transportation for 21st Century Cities". It works like this: a rider contacts the Intelligent Grouping Transportation system with their cellphone, request a pickup (whoa, it's the Matrix), and IGT finds a taxibus whose current route coincides closest with your requested route and routes it to you, "generally within three minutes". Faster and more convenient than a conventional bus and cheaper and more efficient than the single-occupancy door2door taxi. "Analysis indicates that ... as much as a 75% decrease in the number of cars on the roads is feasible".

Like conventional bus systems (at least Ann Arbor's), the largest portion of the cost is the cost of labor, paying drivers. This is why I think we need to put serious efforts into finding automatic (driverless) driving solutions. Though a difficult feat to achieve, I believe it would a silver bullet for bus systems.

In Singapore, Honda is behind an advanced carsharing model called Honda Diracc (Direct Access) whereby members are issued smartcard which are used at a number of special ports to easily check out a car (a Civic Hybrid, even) easily and without pre-booking. This multi-port system has also been in use at UC Riverside since 1999.

Big Motor in Detroit may not wake up to such innovations until it's too late, but carsharing needn't be backed by giant corporations. Last I heard, the Ann Arbor Community Car Co-op (a2c3) was about to have their first car, but were having some insurance difficulties related to the "different" nature of its use, and the conventional pricing would be expensive. I don't think we have the density for a taxibus and without the bigger carsharing companies like exist on the west coast, a co-op may be the only way for it to happen. Until then, there is the AATA bus system as well as the RideShare carpooling community that they back by reimbursing taxi fares when a car fails to show as well as their Night Ride subsidized taxi-sharing.

I currently have a car (of whose existence the insurance company just kindly reminded me) that has sat in the parking structure since my last trip to Columbus. It gets used about once every 1-2 weeks. In another situation, I might be better off getting rid of it altogether, but for two main destinations: Columbus and Detroit. There's no Amtrak from A2 to CMH (besides the fact I'd be fucked in Columbus without a car) and the proposed Lightrail from Ann Arbor to Detroit has been shelved due to state funding going away. Lucky for me, I can afford the luxury of paying hundreds of dollars a month to use my car a few days.


 

Comments

you could rent a car everytime you go to columbus.

Posted by: brette at December 15, 2003 11:48 AM

I just got quotes from a few different car rental places online. To rent a car for a weekend in January, it would be $100 + $30 for being under 25, for the places who will even rent to someone under 25. $130 would be comparable to how much it would cost to travel to Columbus by bus/train/plane so it's not too bad. But I just bought a new car, money isn't the most important issue for me, and if I'm going to have to drive to Columbus, I might as well drive a car I like. The thing that would win me over is being able to sit and read or whatever during the trip instead of having to drive, but also not taking 10 hours to travel 200 miles. Greyhound to Detroit isn't too bad ($13 and as short as 1 hour) except that they don't run very late. Light rail would have been a nice alternative, plus it was going to stop at the airport.

Posted by: agent1073 at December 15, 2003 5:18 PM

i totally agree. by the way, i like your new car. i forgot to mention that when i saw it.

Posted by: brette at December 15, 2003 7:44 PM

What kind of car did you get?

Posted by: ryan at December 15, 2003 10:33 PM

VW GTI GLX (vr6)!

Posted by: agent1073 at December 16, 2003 1:41 AM

it's silver, too

Posted by: brette at December 16, 2003 11:06 AM

Nice. When my car was stolen I was looking at cars and the GTI was high up on my list. Then I started pricing insurance for living and driving in downtown Philadelphia and I decided I did not want to buy another car. It was triple the cost of my insurance from Columbus, and I was already paying $1200/year.

In short, I have decided to put my faith in public transportation. I have to say that I am a little disappointed with Philly's public transit system SEPTA, especially considering the size and population (1.5M).

There is a pretty handy bus that stops across from my apartment (not so handy when you are trying to sleep). The Subway here is a bit limited. I've only taken it twice.

As far as being connected to the rest of the east coast there are a few options. Amtrak runs everywhere over here, but its too expensive. Philly to New York City runs $85 rt, and its only an hour train ride. You can take regional rail lines to get up to NYC for about $30 rt, but it will take you about 2.5 hours.

I want to try the Chinatown to Chinatown busses that connect DC, Philly, NYC and Boston. 2 hours to New York, $20 rt. That beats the regional rail in terms of time and money, and it beats driving because 1) you don't have to drive, 2) you don't have to pay for parking (and in NYC parking is $$$).

I wish the Acela was faster and cheaper. Its about 50% more than a regular Amtrak fare and not much faster.

I've been taking taxis a lot more. If you get 3-4 people in a taxi, then the price drops down to the price of riding a bus.

Posted by: ryan at December 16, 2003 11:56 AM

my brother's taken the china town express NYC to Boston several times and loves it.

Posted by: brette at December 16, 2003 12:35 PM